Arsenal 0-2 Lyon: Outplayed, Outthought & Out Of Excuses?

Arsenal were beaten 2-0 by Olympique Lyonnais in the Champions League, and the scoreline arguably flattered the Gunners. With just five shots, this was a performance that exposed problems extending well beyond one disappointing European result.

Share
Alessia Russo failed to hit the target in Arsenal Women's 2-0 defeat to Lyon | arsenal.com
Alessia Russo failed to hit the target in Arsenal Women's 2-0 defeat to Lyon | arsenal.com

Arsenal have lost 2-0 to Lyon at Meadow Park in the Women's Champions League, with goals from Jule Brand and Melchie Dumornay, and I'm struggling to find much to be pleased about after that performance.

Before the game, I spent a lot of time discussing Lyon's physical strength, the problems we'd experienced against them last season, and how important it was for Arsenal to compete in those individual battles. I was concerned about the difference in strength and athleticism between the two teams, and I wanted to see us finding intelligent ways to deal with it rather than getting dragged into situations where Lyon had a clear advantage.

Well, within the opening 10 minutes it was already obvious that we were going to have an extremely difficult evening, and what bothered me wasn't simply that Lyon were physically stronger. They were quicker to recognise danger, quicker to move into space, more decisive with the ball, and far more organised without it.

They seemed to share a collective understanding of what they were trying to do that Arsenal simply didn't.

Renée made two changes from Sunday's draw against London City Lionesses. Ona Batlle was unavailable after picking up an injury, so Taylor Hinds came in at left-back, while Kyra Cooney-Cross replaced Kim Little in midfield. We had Misa in goal, Emily Fox, Leah Williamson, Élisa de Almeida and Taylor across the back, with Kyra and Georgia Stanway behind Frida Maanum, Lisa Baum and Caitlin Foord, and Alessia Russo leading the attack.

I was disappointed to see Ona missing, because I thought she was excellent on Sunday and I'd been looking forward to seeing how she might cope with Lyon's attacking players, but that starting eleven still had plenty of experience. We weren't putting out a team of youngsters who'd never faced European opposition before. These are established international footballers, several of whom have played in enormous matches for club and country, and that's why I found what followed so difficult to accept.

Lyon were moving the ball with an ease that became almost embarrassing to watch. Whenever one of their players received possession, someone seemed available to support her, another player making a run, and somebody else anticipating where the next pass would go. Arsenal, by comparison, looked as though we were reacting to events after they'd already happened.

Vicki Bècho was causing problems early on, and in the 8th minute Misa had to make an important save after Melchie Dumornay produced a lovely backheel that sent Bècho into space behind Taylor Hinds. The finish came from a narrow angle, but Misa had to react quickly to turn it away.

That should have been an early warning, because Lyon were already finding ways to get behind our defensive line, and at times our players simply weren't communicating well enough to prevent those situations from developing.

We did manage an attacking move around the 13th minute, when Lisa Baum helped release Alessia Russo down the left, but Lyon recovered and conceded a corner. There were appeals for handball when the delivery came into the penalty area, but nothing was given, and Arsenal didn't build any meaningful pressure from it.

On the rare occasions we got into a promising position, we showed little conviction about what happened next. We'd take an extra touch, choose a pass that wasn't really going anywhere or fail to recognise a run that might have created something. Lyon did those things instinctively, while Arsenal seemed to have to think through every decision.

In the 24th minute, Lyon took the lead, and for me it was a goal that captured several of the problems we'd been watching.

Arsenal tried to play through Lyon's press when Kyra Cooney-Cross lost possession; Lily Yohannes moved the ball out to Bècho, and she found Jule Brand making a run into the penalty area. Brand arrived with far too much space and finished comfortably past Misa at the near post.

Arsenal 0, Lyon 1.

I want you to think about that sequence, because it wasn't simply one midfielder losing the ball and everybody else being unfortunate. Lyon pressed us into a mistake, reacted immediately when they won possession and had players moving into dangerous positions before our defence could organise itself.

Where was the communication? Who was recognising Brand's run? Why were we letting someone arrive in that position without anyone getting close enough to make the finish difficult?

Individual mistakes are inevitable in football, and even the best players lose possession, but good teams have systems and relationships that help them deal with those moments. They recognise when someone is exposed, they cover for one another, and they communicate before the danger becomes a clear goalscoring opportunity.

Tonight, too often, Arsenal looked like a collection of individuals trying to solve problems on their own.

Lyon could have doubled their lead just a few minutes later when Jule Brand found Marie-Antoinette Katoto between Leah Williamson and Élisa de Almeida. Katoto had an excellent chance but sent her volley over the bar, and that was another moment when we were extremely fortunate not to be punished.

We finally registered our first shot after about 34 minutes, when Arsenal won possession high up the pitch, and Alessia Russo's effort was blocked. By that stage, Lyon had already created chance after chance, and we struggled to put together anything that looked like a sustained attack.

Lily Yohannes went close with a curling effort, Tabitha Chawinga got in behind our defence, and Misa and the defenders had to make several last-minute interventions just to stop Lyon from extending their lead.

Arsenal's play had very little bite, and I'm not talking about going around kicking opponents or collecting yellow cards. I mean the kind of intensity that makes an opponent uncomfortable. The willingness to close somebody down immediately, to fight for a loose ball, to anticipate a pass and get there first. Lyon had that all over the pitch, and we seemed to be arriving second far too often.

What struck me most was that we weren't being beaten by some remarkable tactical innovation. Lyon were doing the basics at an incredibly high level. Their passing was sharper, their movement was better, and their players seemed to know exactly what their teammates were going to do.

We had no answer.

By half-time Lyon had enjoyed almost 70% possession and taken 12 shots to Arsenal's one, and the only surprising thing about the score was that we were still just one goal behind.

I know we went to Barcelona last week and spent much of that game defending, but at least there were moments when you could see what Arsenal were trying to achieve. We had a clear plan to make life difficult for them; we took an opportunity to score, and we became more competitive during the second half.

Against Lyon, I couldn't see that same understanding.

When I looked at the players walking off at half-time, I wasn't thinking about how unlucky we'd been to concede or whether a couple of small adjustments might turn the game around.

I wondered how a squad with this much talent and experience could look so far from being a functioning team.

Lyon Should Have Put Four Or Five Past Us

When the teams came back out for the second half, I was looking for some evidence that Renée had managed to get through to the players during the interval, because we'd been so poor during the opening 45 minutes that something had to change. I wasn't expecting us to suddenly start dominating Lyon, but I wanted to see some organisation, some aggression when we didn't have the ball and a willingness to take responsibility when we did.

Above all, I wanted Arsenal to look like they still believed they could get something from the game.

We had a little more possession in the opening stages, and we did manage to get further up the pitch, but the problem was that we weren't doing anything useful with it. We'd move the ball across midfield, occasionally work it into a promising position and then seem to run out of ideas. There was very little movement ahead of the player in possession, nobody making the sort of unexpected run that forces a defender to turn and too many occasions when the safest pass seemed to be the only option anyone was prepared to take.

We looked painfully predictable.

Lyon, on the other hand, kept finding opportunities whenever they increased the tempo, and in the 57th minute Melchie Dumornay made it 2-0.

It was another example of how quickly they could move from winning possession to threatening our goal, and once Dumornay found herself in a position to finish, she made absolutely no mistake.

Arsenal 0, Lyon 2.

At that point, I wasn't thinking about whether we could produce another Barcelona-style comeback or whether one goal might change the momentum. I was genuinely concerned about how many more Lyon might score, because there was so little evidence Arsenal could take control of any aspect of the game.

Marie-Antoinette Katoto had opportunities to make the scoreline considerably worse, and Misa Rodríguez had to make more important saves. I've praised Misa quite a lot recently, and I don't want to spend another section going through everything we've already said about how good she is, but a wider point concerns me. When your goalkeeper is regularly one of your most important performers, particularly in games where the opposition are creating chance after chance, you have to ask why she's being required to do so much work in the first place.

Renée began making changes, and I hoped the substitutes would bring fresh energy and a different approach to our attacking play, but what bothered me was how little changed in how we functioned as a team.

Bringing on another talented footballer doesn't automatically solve the problem if she's entering a side where the movement, communication and passing options still aren't working.

Géraldine Reuteler eventually came on, and I have to say I was pleased to see her getting onto the pitch after everything that's happened this week, but I was also frustrated by the circumstances. By the time she was introduced, Lyon were comfortably in control, Arsenal were struggling to create anything, and there was very little time for her to influence the result.

She was also asked to operate on the right side of midfield again, and I know plenty of supporters have questioned why we keep using her there when so much of her football at Frankfurt showed how effective she can be in central areas.

I've made my views on that position clear in previous episodes, and I'm not going to repeat the entire argument tonight. But I do want to make one point, because I've seen supporters suggesting that Géraldine is being set up to fail, and while I understand why people are frustrated, I don't believe we should make that accusation as though we know Renée's intentions.

We don't.

What we can say is that Géraldine has received very limited opportunities, she's frequently been used in a position that doesn't appear to make the best use of her qualities, and tonight she was introduced into a game that was already slipping beyond Arsenal's reach. Those are reasonable questions, especially given reports of a possible January loan.

But I wouldn't judge her on what she could contribute in those circumstances, any more than I'd judge any other substitute asked to change a game when the entire team was struggling.

What I found almost unbelievable was that Arsenal didn't register a shot on target until Emily Fox finally tested the Lyon goalkeeper in the 94th minute.

The 94th minute!

We're talking about Arsenal Women, playing a Champions League game at home, with Alessia Russo leading the attack and some very talented footballers around her, and we went virtually the entire evening without forcing the opposition goalkeeper to make a save.

We managed just 5 shots throughout the game, only one on target, while Lyon had 20. And those numbers reflected what I'd been watching, because Arsenal never looked capable of putting Lyon under the sort of pressure they'd been putting us under.

There wasn't enough movement, imagination, or urgency to get players into the penalty area when the opportunity presented itself. Alessia spent much of the evening trying to make something happen without the support she needed, and when we did manage to work the ball forward, the final decision was too often slow or ineffective.

Following the London City game, I was encouraged by the energy and purpose Arsenal showed, even though we still lacked that little bit of quality and ruthlessness in the final action.

Tonight, we didn't even get far enough forward regularly for that to become our biggest problem.

There was no attacking rhythm to speak of, and that concerns me far more than a couple of missed chances because it suggests something fundamentally wrong with how we're trying to play.

By the final whistle, Lyon had won 2-0, and while I'm sure their players will have been delighted with another Champions League victory, I wouldn't be surprised if they were slightly disappointed not to have scored more.

Some evenings you lose to an outstanding opponent despite playing well, and you can accept that because you've seen your players compete, create opportunities, and prove they belong at that level.

This wasn't one of those evenings.

Lyon were excellent, but Arsenal made their job far too easy.

Renée Slegers: How Much Longer Can This Continue

There's something Renée Slegers said after the game that I want to come back to, because I listened to her reaction and found myself becoming increasingly frustrated, not because she refused to acknowledge that Lyon were better, because she did, but because I'm beginning to wonder whether we're getting any closer to understanding why Arsenal are struggling so badly.

She congratulated Lyon, accepted they deserved to win, and pointed to the demanding run of fixtures we've had recently: Liverpool away, Barcelona away, London City Lionesses, and now Lyon, all coming within a relatively short period. She also talked about the limited recovery time between matches, and I understand that argument because we've played some excellent teams in quick succession; several players have carried an enormous workload, and injuries have reduced her options.

But here's my problem with that explanation.

We knew what the schedule looked like. We knew we'd be competing in the Women's Super League and Champions League; we knew there would be weeks when we'd have very little time between games, and we've assembled a squad specifically to cope with those demands. Lyon have their own advantages when it comes to rotation, and we discussed those before the match, but Arsenal aren't a small club trying to survive their first European campaign with 14 senior players.

We're one of the biggest clubs in women's football, with significant resources and a squad full of established internationals.

So while fatigue might help explain why certain players weren't as sharp as we'd like, it doesn't explain the enormous gaps between our lines, why the attacking structure failed, or why we repeatedly struggled to recognise what Lyon were about to do until the danger was already developing.

Those are questions about coaching, preparation and organisation, and I believe the manager has to take responsibility for them.

I also want to be careful here, because I'm not one of those supporters who believes every disappointing result means the manager should be sacked immediately. Football doesn't work like that, and when a team is going through a difficult period, sometimes the sensible thing is to give the coaching staff time to address the problems rather than making changes every time somebody gets angry on social media.

But patience has to be based on evidence that things are moving in the right direction, and that's where I'm struggling with Arsenal right now.

We've spent weeks discussing our difficulties in the league, the points we've dropped at the Emirates and our inability to turn possession and opportunities into victories. Following the draw with London City, I was encouraged because I'd seen better movement, more energy and a greater willingness to play forward. I thought there were signs that some of the work being done on the training ground was beginning to make a difference.

Tonight, against an opponent who exposed every weakness we have, those improvements disappeared.

I don't expect Arsenal to dominate Lyon, and I certainly don't expect us to beat every elite European opponent simply because we've got talented players. But I do expect us to compete, and by that I mean showing some understanding of how we're going to deal with the opposition, where we're going to find space when we have the ball and how we're going to work together when we lose it.

That shouldn't be too much to ask.

What concerns me is that the problems aren't confined to one area of the pitch. If we were defending well but struggling to score, we could concentrate on what needs to change in attack. If we were creating chances but conceding too many goals, we'd have a clearer idea of where to focus.

At the moment, though, I'm watching Arsenal struggle to defend as a unit, struggle to control midfield against stronger opponents and struggle to produce anything meaningful in attack. Those aren't three completely separate problems, because how a team is organised affects everything it does, and when those relationships stop working, even excellent individual footballers can start to look ordinary.

That's why I keep coming back to the lack of leadership I saw tonight.

I'm not simply talking about whether Leah Williamson or Georgia Stanway was shouting instructions, because I couldn't possibly hear every conversation taking place on the pitch, and I wouldn't pretend otherwise. I'm talking about the leadership you can see in how a team responds when something goes wrong. Who takes responsibility for calming things down? Who recognises that the midfield needs help? Who changes their position to give a teammate an option when they're being pressed?

I didn't see enough of that from Arsenal.

At times, we looked like we were waiting for someone else to solve the problem, and that's hard to accept from a group with so much international experience.

But leadership isn't only the responsibility of the captain or the senior players. It has to come from the touchline too, because Renée and her coaching staff are responsible for establishing the structure those players operate within. When a team looks uncertain about its responsibilities, you have to question whether the instructions are clear enough, whether the players believe in what they're being asked to do and whether the manager is making the adjustments needed when something isn't working.

I want to see evidence that Renée can identify a problem while a game is unfolding and make changes that alter the way Arsenal are playing, rather than simply introducing fresh players into the same difficulties.

That brings me to something else that's been bothering me: the relationship between our recruitment and the football we're trying to play.

Arsenal have brought in some excellent players, but having an impressive collection of individuals isn't the same as building a balanced team. We've discussed the positional decisions, the lack of continuity for certain players and the difficulty some of our new signings have had establishing themselves, and I'm increasingly concerned that we're not getting anything like the collective performance this squad should be capable of producing.

This is where I believe questions have to be asked beyond Renée herself, because somebody is responsible for deciding which players Arsenal recruit, how those players fit the manager's plans and whether the coaching staff have what they need to deliver the football the club expects.

If those decisions aren't working, accountability cannot stop with the person standing on the touchline.

But equally, Renée is the head coach, and we cannot keep using the quality of the opposition, the injury list or the fixture schedule to avoid examining what she's getting wrong.

I've seen increasingly vocal calls for Renée to leave, and after tonight I can understand why supporters are reaching that conclusion. They're looking at the players we have, the results, and they're struggling to recognise the Arsenal team they expected to see.

Some people will say it's ridiculous to question the manager after losing to Lyon, one of the strongest teams in Europe, but I think that misses the point entirely.

It's not simply that we lost to Lyon.

It's how we lost, how little we offered in response and how many of the problems we've been discussing for weeks were exposed again.

Does that mean I believe Arsenal should sack Renée tomorrow morning?

I'm not prepared to make that judgement on the strength of one European defeat, and I don't know enough about the internal situation to claim that replacing her would automatically solve everything. But I also don't believe she should be protected from criticism simply because she led Arsenal to Champions League success or because changing managers would be uncomfortable.

Past success earns respect. It doesn't make somebody immune from accountability.

What I want to know is whether the people running Arsenal can see the same problems supporters are seeing, whether they understand how serious those problems have become and whether there's a convincing plan to address them.

Because if the plan is to keep doing much the same thing and hope that our talented players eventually find a way to make it work, I'm afraid that isn't good enough.

What The Defeat Means For Arsenal In Europe

The defeat leaves Arsenal 8th in the Champions League standings with 8 points from five games, and that means our hopes of finishing in the top four and qualifying directly for the quarter-finals have taken a serious blow.

We've got one league-phase game remaining, away to Inter Milan on 16 December, and while we can still finish in those automatic qualification places, we're now relying on other results going our way as well as getting the job done ourselves. If we don't manage that, we'll have to go through an additional knockout play-off round, which is hardly ideal given the number of games we've already got to contend with.

But I have to tell you, after watching what happened against Lyon, I'm struggling to get excited about working out all the different combinations of results that might help us finish 4th, because something much more immediate needs addressing.

We have to start playing like a team again.

We've reached a point in the season where the squad's quality isn't the question. We've got some excellent footballers, we've got experienced internationals and we've got players capable of performing against the strongest opposition in Europe.

What we don't have consistently is a team that looks capable of making the most of them.

The European standings matter, and of course I want Arsenal to finish as high as possible, but we cannot keep focusing on the consequences of disappointing results without examining why they're happening.

That has to be the priority.

Final Thoughts

Arsenal 0, Lyon 2, and I'm finding it difficult to remember the last time I watched us look quite so far away from the level of football we should be capable of producing.

Lyon were excellent, and they deserve enormous credit for their performance, but the difference between the teams went well beyond the scoreline. They looked organised, confident, and completely comfortable in what they were trying to achieve, while Arsenal seemed to struggle with things that should be second nature to a squad of experienced international footballers.

Something isn't working, and I don't believe a couple of better results will automatically fix it.

I don't know whether changing the manager would solve those problems, and I wouldn't claim to have all the answers from watching games and following the club as closely as I do. But I know what I saw against Lyon, and I know it wasn't good enough.

We're not expecting miracles. We're expecting a team with this much talent and experience to compete, show some imagination, and give supporters a reason to believe there's something worth building towards.

Right now, I'm struggling to see enough of that.

We've got West Ham coming to the Emirates on Sunday, and I'll be back on Saturday with a full preview of that game, because I think it'll be an important afternoon for Arsenal and Renée Slegers.

Before I finish, I'd love to hear your thoughts on the Lyon game. Do you believe Renée should be given more time to turn things around, or have you reached the point where you think Arsenal need a change? And how much responsibility do you place on the players and the people making decisions above the manager?

Come and find me on Instagram at @arsenalwomentrailblazers and let me know. I know emotions are running high at the moment, and there will be some strong opinions, but that's fine.

Please remember that we can disagree about the manager and individual performances while still wanting the same thing for our club!