Géraldine Reuteler: Why Are Arsenal Women Already Considering a January Loan?

After pursuing Géraldine Reuteler for more than a year, why has the club given her so few opportunities to establish herself, and why is there now talk of her going out on loan in January?

Share
Géraldine Reuteler celebrates scoring for Switzerland during the Women's Euros 2025, her future at Arsenal is in doubt

The Athletic reports that Arsenal are exploring a loan move for Géraldine Reuteler in January, with at least two Women's Super League clubs apparently interested in taking her for the rest of the season.

Just think about that for a moment.

We spent more than a year pursuing this player. Arsenal - specifically Renée Slegers - wanted her in 2025, couldn't convince Eintracht Frankfurt to sell her and eventually brought her to London this summer when her contract expired. Renée Slegers spoke to her about the move; the club clearly believed she could improve our midfield, and we were signing someone who'd established herself as one of the best players in the Bundesliga.

Four months later, we're apparently considering sending her elsewhere because she's barely getting on the pitch.

Can somebody explain how that makes any sense?

This isn't a promising 19-year-old who's arrived at a big club and needs a season of regular football elsewhere to continue her development. Géraldine is 27 years old; she's an established Swiss international; she was vice-captain at Frankfurt; and she came to Arsenal after eight years in Germany because she wanted to test herself against the best players in the Women's Super League.

She knew there would be competition for places. In fact, that was one reason she wanted to come here.

What she presumably didn't expect was to spend most of her first few months watching from the bench, occasionally getting a handful of minutes and then, when she finally started two consecutive games against Benfica and Aston Villa, finding herself back on the bench without another opportunity.

I've said before that I thought she played well against Benfica, especially given how little competitive football she'd had with her new teammates, and I saw qualities in that performance that made me excited about what she might contribute. Her movement, her intelligence in possession and the way she found space between opponents were all encouraging, even if she wasn't perfect.

She was taken off at half-time against Aston Villa, and we haven't seen her play since.

That's the part I find so difficult to accept. We're not talking about a player who's had a sustained run of games and demonstrated that she cannot cope with the demands of English football. We're talking about someone who hasn't been given anything approaching a proper opportunity to establish herself.

Renée sees the players in training, and there may be footballing reasons behind her decisions that we don't know about. I'm perfectly prepared to acknowledge that. But when a club works so hard to sign an experienced international footballer, and that player is then barely used before reports emerge of a potential January loan, supporters are entitled to ask serious questions about the recruitment process and the manager's squad management.

Either Arsenal recruited someone who doesn't fit what Renée wants, despite the fact that Renée herself wanted her, or we recruited someone with the qualities we needed and have since failed to find a way to use them.

Neither explanation reflects well on the people making those decisions.

The Person Behind the Footballer

But another part of this story matters enormously to me, and it's the part I want you to consider before you decide this is simply another footballer who needs to move clubs to get some minutes.

Back in September, I published a long profile of Géraldine on the Trailblazers website. I spent weeks researching her life and career, going all the way back to her childhood in Stans, because I wanted people to understand the person behind the footballer.

There's a section in that article about her move to Frankfurt in 2018 that I'd really encourage you to read.

Géraldine was 19 when she left Switzerland for Germany, and although she'd already spent years travelling and living away from home through the Swiss football development system, she found that move incredibly difficult. She became terribly homesick, just as she had when she first left her family at 12, and she had to work incredibly hard to make somewhere unfamiliar feel like home.

Over time, Frankfurt became exactly that.

She spent eight years there. She developed as a footballer, became one of the club's senior players and eventually its vice-captain. When she suffered a devastating knee injury that kept her out for almost a year, Frankfurt supported her, offered her a new contract while she was still recovering and helped her rebuild her career.

She described the club as her second family.

I want you to hold that thought for a moment, because when Géraldine decided to leave Frankfurt for Arsenal, she wasn't escaping somewhere she was unhappy. She was leaving a place where she was valued, where she belonged and where she'd built an enormous part of her adult life.

She chose to leave all of that behind because she believed Arsenal was the right place to take the next step in her career.

I find that incredibly moving when I look back on everything I've learned about her, because she's spoken openly about how difficult those transitions have been throughout her life. She'd finally established herself somewhere comfortable and familiar, and she was prepared to take that risk all over again because she wanted to become an even better footballer.

Imagine making that decision, arriving at one of the biggest clubs in women's football, and then barely being given the chance to do the thing you came here to do.

I don't know how Géraldine is feeling today, and I wouldn't presume to speak for her. But I do know footballers are human beings, and when we discuss recruitment, squad depth, and whether a loan might make sense, it's easy to forget there's a person whose entire life has been affected by those decisions.

That's why this bothers me so much.

What Responsibility Does Arsenal Have?

I don't believe Renée owes Géraldine a guaranteed place in the starting eleven. Nobody should be selected simply because they've got an impressive CV or because supporters are demanding it. But I do believe that when a manager helps persuade an established player to leave a club where she's spent eight years, there's a responsibility to have a clear plan for how that player will contribute.

If the plan changes, explain it. If the player needs to improve something, work with her. If the recruitment hasn't worked, then the people responsible need to acknowledge that and examine why.

What I cannot understand is how we've reached the middle of November with so little evidence that Arsenal have seriously attempted to integrate Géraldine into this team.

Judging by the reaction to today's reports, I'm far from the only supporter asking that question. I've seen plenty of anger and disbelief from Arsenal fans who cannot understand why we signed her in the first place if this is how things were going to unfold.

I'm angry too, and I'm not going to pretend otherwise simply because I love this football club.

In fact, I think loving Arsenal is precisely why we should be prepared to ask difficult questions of the people running it.

This is an experienced international footballer who chose Arsenal because she believed it was the right place for her future. At the moment, from everything we can see publicly, that decision hasn't been rewarded with anything resembling the opportunity she came here for.

Maybe a loan eventually becomes the best solution for Géraldine. If playing somewhere else lets her regain regular football, enjoy herself on the pitch, and keep developing her career, then of course I'd want that for her.

But I would find it incredibly sad if the best thing Arsenal can offer a player they pursued for more than a year is the chance to leave after half a season.

That's not something I'd consider a successful piece of recruitment, and Renée Slegers and the people responsible for bringing Géraldine to this club have some serious questions to answer.

If you haven't read my original profile of Géraldine Reuteler, please do. I hope that after reading it you'll look at this situation a little differently, because we're talking about considerably more than another name on a team sheet.